Hey car enthusiasts! Let's dive into a head-to-head comparison of two iconic sports cars that share a lot of DNA: the Scion FR-S and the Toyota 86. These cars have captured the hearts of driving enthusiasts with their engaging driving dynamics, rear-wheel-drive setup, and affordable price point. But what exactly are the differences, and which one should you choose? Let's break it down!

A Tale of Two Badges: FR-S and 86

The Scion FR-S and Toyota 86 are essentially the same car, but with different badges and minor tweaks due to their respective brands. The FR-S was initially launched under Toyota's Scion brand, which was aimed at younger buyers. When Scion was discontinued in 2016, the FR-S was rebadged as the Toyota 86. So, if you're looking at models from 2012 to 2016, you'll find the FR-S, while models from 2017 onwards are the Toyota 86. Despite the badge differences, the core DNA of these cars remains consistent, offering a thrilling driving experience that emphasizes handling and driver engagement.

When comparing these models, it's important to understand their shared history and how they evolved over time. Both cars were developed as a joint venture between Toyota and Subaru, with Subaru providing the engine and Toyota contributing to the design and engineering. This collaboration resulted in a lightweight, rear-wheel-drive sports car that quickly gained popularity for its balanced handling and responsive steering. The FR-S and 86 are known for their ability to make drivers of all skill levels feel confident behind the wheel, thanks to their predictable behavior and communicative chassis. Whether you're a seasoned track enthusiast or a casual weekend driver, these cars offer an engaging and rewarding experience that's hard to find in other vehicles in their price range. The significance of their shared platform cannot be overstated, as it ensures that both models deliver a similar level of performance and driving pleasure, making the choice between them largely a matter of personal preference and availability.

Under the Hood: Engine and Performance

Discussing the heart of the matter, the engine, both the FR-S and 86 are powered by a 2.0-liter naturally aspirated Subaru boxer engine. This engine delivers around 200 horsepower and 151 lb-ft of torque. While the numbers might not seem staggering, the lightweight chassis and rear-wheel-drive layout make these cars incredibly fun to drive. The boxer engine's low center of gravity also contributes to the car's excellent handling characteristics. However, some enthusiasts have criticized the engine for its notorious torque dip in the mid-range, which can affect acceleration in certain situations. Despite this, the engine's high-revving nature and distinctive exhaust note add to the overall driving experience.

The engine's responsiveness and willingness to rev make it a joy to explore the car's handling limits. Both the FR-S and 86 come standard with a six-speed manual transmission, which is the preferred choice for most enthusiasts due to its precise shifts and engaging feel. A six-speed automatic transmission is also available, but it doesn't offer the same level of driver involvement. The manual transmission allows drivers to fully exploit the engine's powerband and maintain optimal control during spirited driving. Furthermore, the car's lightweight design means that even with modest horsepower figures, it feels quick and nimble on the road. The combination of a responsive engine, precise transmission, and balanced chassis makes the FR-S and 86 incredibly rewarding to drive, whether you're carving through mountain roads or navigating city streets.

Exterior and Interior: What's the Difference?

Aesthetically, the differences between the Scion FR-S and Toyota 86 are subtle but noticeable. The FR-S had a more understated design with a focus on simplicity, while the Toyota 86 received minor styling updates, including revised headlights, taillights, and bumpers, giving it a slightly more aggressive and modern appearance. Inside, both cars feature a driver-focused cockpit with supportive seats and a simple, functional layout. The materials used are generally durable but not particularly luxurious, reflecting the car's emphasis on performance over outright comfort. However, the Toyota 86 did receive some interior upgrades, such as improved upholstery and a slightly redesigned dashboard.

One of the most significant exterior changes on the Toyota 86 was the addition of LED headlights and taillights, which not only improved visibility but also gave the car a more contemporary look. The revised front bumper and grille also contributed to a more aggressive stance. Inside, the Toyota 86 offered optional features such as আলকানতারা inserts and contrast stitching, which added a touch of refinement to the cabin. While the basic layout remained the same, these small improvements helped to elevate the overall feel of the interior. Despite these differences, both cars share the same fundamental design principles, prioritizing driver engagement and a connected feel. The focus on simplicity and functionality ensures that the driver can concentrate on the road ahead without unnecessary distractions. Whether you prefer the understated look of the FR-S or the slightly more modern styling of the 86, both cars offer a compelling package for driving enthusiasts.

Handling and Driving Dynamics

The handling and driving dynamics are where the FR-S and 86 truly shine. Both cars offer sharp, precise steering, minimal body roll, and a well-balanced chassis that makes them incredibly fun to drive on twisty roads. The rear-wheel-drive layout allows for easy oversteer, making them popular among drifting enthusiasts. The suspension is firm but not overly harsh, providing a good balance between comfort and performance. The limited-slip differential helps to improve traction and cornering ability, while the responsive brakes offer plenty of stopping power. Overall, the FR-S and 86 deliver a pure and engaging driving experience that's hard to find in modern cars.

The communicative chassis and responsive steering inspire confidence, allowing drivers to explore the car's limits without feeling overwhelmed. Both the FR-S and 86 are known for their predictable behavior, making them excellent platforms for learning and improving driving skills. The ability to easily induce and control oversteer adds to the fun factor, making these cars popular choices for track days and autocross events. However, it's important to note that the low-grip tires can make the car feel a bit twitchy in slippery conditions, so it's essential to exercise caution when driving in the wet. Despite this, the FR-S and 86 offer a rewarding and engaging driving experience that's sure to put a smile on your face, every time you get behind the wheel. The emphasis on driver involvement and connection sets them apart from many modern sports cars, making them a favorite among enthusiasts who appreciate the art of driving.

Reliability and Maintenance

Reliability and maintenance are important considerations when purchasing any car. Both the FR-S and 86 have proven to be relatively reliable, with few major issues reported. However, some owners have experienced problems with the fuel injectors and valve springs, particularly in early models. Regular maintenance, such as oil changes and filter replacements, is essential to keep these cars running smoothly. The boxer engine design can make some maintenance tasks more challenging than on traditional inline engines, but overall, the FR-S and 86 are relatively easy to own and maintain. The availability of aftermarket parts and support is also excellent, making it easy to customize and upgrade these cars to suit your individual needs.

One of the key factors contributing to the reliability of the FR-S and 86 is their simple and straightforward design. Unlike many modern cars, they don't rely on complex electronic systems or advanced technologies that can be prone to failure. The emphasis on mechanical components ensures that these cars are relatively easy to diagnose and repair. However, it's important to keep in mind that the boxer engine requires regular oil changes and careful attention to avoid potential issues. Some owners have also reported problems with the direct injection system, which can lead to carbon buildup on the valves. Despite these minor issues, the FR-S and 86 have generally proven to be reliable and dependable cars. The strong community support and readily available parts make them a great choice for enthusiasts who enjoy working on their own cars. Overall, the FR-S and 86 offer a compelling blend of performance, reliability, and affordability, making them a popular choice among driving enthusiasts.

Pricing and Availability

Pricing and availability can vary depending on the model year, condition, and location. Generally, the Scion FR-S tends to be slightly more affordable than the Toyota 86, especially for earlier model years. However, prices can fluctuate depending on the market and demand. Both cars are widely available in the used market, with a wide range of options to choose from. When shopping for an FR-S or 86, it's important to carefully inspect the car for any signs of damage or wear and tear. A pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic is always a good idea to ensure that the car is in good condition and free from any hidden problems. With a bit of research and patience, you can find a great deal on an FR-S or 86 that fits your budget and needs.

The value proposition of both the FR-S and 86 is hard to beat. These cars offer a level of performance and driving enjoyment that's typically found in much more expensive vehicles. The affordable price point makes them accessible to a wide range of buyers, while the low running costs and reliable mechanicals make them easy to own and maintain. Whether you're a seasoned track enthusiast or a casual weekend driver, the FR-S and 86 offer a compelling package that's sure to impress. The strong community support and readily available parts make them a great choice for enthusiasts who enjoy customizing and upgrading their cars. Overall, the FR-S and 86 represent excellent value for money, offering a thrilling driving experience without breaking the bank.

Which One Should You Choose?

Deciding which one you should choose ultimately depends on your personal preferences and budget. If you're looking for the most affordable option, the Scion FR-S is a great choice. If you prefer the updated styling and interior of the Toyota 86, then it might be worth spending a bit more. Keep in mind that the driving experience is virtually identical between the two cars, so you can't go wrong with either one. Ultimately, the best way to decide is to test drive both cars and see which one you prefer.

Factors to consider include the model year, condition, mileage, and any modifications that have been made to the car. It's also important to consider your personal driving style and needs. If you plan to use the car primarily for commuting, then the automatic transmission might be a better choice. If you're a more experienced driver who enjoys spirited driving, then the manual transmission is the way to go. Regardless of which one you choose, you're sure to enjoy the engaging and rewarding driving experience that the FR-S and 86 have to offer. So, go out there and find the perfect sports car for you!

In conclusion, both the Scion FR-S and Toyota 86 are fantastic sports cars that offer a thrilling driving experience at an affordable price. While there are some minor differences in styling and features, the core DNA of these cars remains the same. Whether you choose the FR-S or the 86, you're sure to enjoy the sharp handling, responsive engine, and engaging driving dynamics that these cars are known for. So, get behind the wheel and experience the joy of driving a true sports car!