Hey there, partners! If you're wandering around in Red Dead Redemption 2 and stumbled upon a fella named Danbury, you might be wondering if you should let him meet his maker or spare his hide. It's a classic moral quandary that the game throws at you, and the decision isn't always straightforward. So, let's dive deep into who Danbury is, the consequences of your actions, and whether pulling that trigger is worth it.

Who is Danbury?

Danbury isn't some major character you'll find plastered all over the main storyline. He's more of a random encounter, a blip on Arthur Morgan's radar. You'll typically find him in need of assistance, perhaps caught in a sticky situation or down on his luck. The specifics can vary, adding a bit of spice to each playthrough. These encounters are what make the world of RDR2 feel so alive and unpredictable, and Danbury's plight is just one example. Think of him as a microcosm of the hard choices and moral ambiguities that permeate the Wild West. Is he a genuinely good person who's just had a run of bad luck? Or is he a con artist trying to pull a fast one on a kind-hearted stranger? That's the question you'll have to wrestle with.

Danbury's situation might tug at your heartstrings, or it might raise your suspicions. Maybe he's been robbed and left for dead, or perhaps he's got a sob story about needing money to get back home to his family. It's in these moments that Red Dead Redemption 2 shines, forcing you to make split-second decisions based on limited information. Do you trust your gut? Do you play it safe? Or do you gamble on the chance that you're helping someone in genuine need?

The beauty of these random encounters is that they add layers of depth to Arthur Morgan's character. Are you a ruthless outlaw who cares only about personal gain? Or are you a flawed but ultimately decent man trying to make your way in a harsh world? Your interactions with characters like Danbury shape Arthur's narrative, influencing his honor rating and ultimately affecting the trajectory of the story. So, before you decide whether to send Danbury to the great beyond, take a moment to consider what kind of Arthur Morgan you want to be. Are you a dispenser of frontier justice, or a beacon of hope in a lawless land? The choice, as always, is yours.

The Consequences of Your Actions

Alright, so you've met Danbury, heard his story, and now you're standing at a crossroads. Do you help him out, or do you decide he's not worth the trouble (or worse, deserves a bullet)? Here's the lowdown on what can happen depending on your choice:

Helping Danbury

If you decide to lend Danbury a hand, you might see your honor rating tick upwards. Helping those in need is generally a good deed in the eyes of the game, and Arthur's reputation will reflect that. Plus, you never know when that good karma might come back around. Danbury might offer you a small reward, or he could promise to repay you in the future. Sometimes, these promises materialize in unexpected ways, leading to new opportunities or discounts at local stores. It's all part of the interconnected world that Rockstar Games has crafted.

But be warned, not every act of kindness is rewarded. Sometimes, Danbury might turn out to be a charlatan, taking your money and running. This can lead to a dip in your honor rating, as Arthur is seen as gullible or foolish. It's a harsh lesson in the realities of the Wild West, where trust is a rare and precious commodity. Even if Danbury is genuine, your help might not solve his problems. He could still meet a tragic end, despite your best efforts. This is a reminder that Arthur can't save everyone, and sometimes, all you can do is offer a moment of respite in a cruel and unforgiving world.

Killing Danbury

Now, let's talk about the darker path. If you decide that Danbury needs to be eliminated, whether out of suspicion, greed, or sheer bloodlust, be prepared for the consequences. Your honor rating will take a hit, marking Arthur as a cold-blooded killer. This can affect how other characters react to you, leading to suspicion, hostility, or even outright aggression. Shopkeepers might charge you higher prices, lawmen might be more likely to stop and search you, and even your fellow gang members might start to look at you differently. A reputation for violence can be a heavy burden to bear.

Of course, there might be some immediate benefits to snuffing out Danbury's flame. You could loot his body for valuables, adding a few extra dollars to your pocket. But is the short-term gain worth the long-term consequences? That's a question you'll have to ask yourself. And remember, the world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is full of surprises. Killing Danbury might trigger unforeseen events, leading to new challenges or opportunities. Perhaps he was connected to a powerful gang, and his death will bring their wrath upon you. Or maybe he was hiding a valuable secret, and his demise will lead you on a treasure hunt. The possibilities are endless.

The Moral of the Story

Ultimately, the decision of whether to help or harm Danbury is up to you. There's no right or wrong answer, and the consequences of your actions will ripple through the game world in unpredictable ways. What's important is that you consider the implications of your choice and make a decision that aligns with the kind of Arthur Morgan you want to portray.

So, Should You Pull the Trigger?

Alright, let's get down to the nitty-gritty. Should you actually waste Danbury? Well, here's a breakdown to help you make up your mind:

Reasons to Eliminate Danbury

• He's a Liar: Maybe your gut is screaming that Danbury is pulling a fast one. If you're convinced he's trying to con you, then eliminating him could be seen as a form of self-preservation. After all, you don't want to be taken advantage of, right?
• Loot: Let's be honest, sometimes the temptation of a quick buck is too strong to resist. If Danbury is carrying some valuable items, you might be tempted to take them by force. Just be prepared for the consequences to your honor rating.
• Roleplaying a Bad Guy: Maybe you're playing a ruthless outlaw who cares about nothing but themselves. In that case, killing Danbury could be a way to stay in character and embrace the darker side of the Wild West.

Reasons to Spare Danbury

• He's Genuine: If you believe Danbury is truly in need of help, then lending him a hand could be a rewarding experience. You'll feel good about yourself, and you might even earn some positive karma along the way.
• Honor: Maintaining a high honor rating can unlock certain benefits in the game, such as discounts at stores and more favorable interactions with NPCs. Sparing Danbury could help you stay on the path of righteousness.
• Unpredictability: Sometimes, the most interesting outcomes come from unexpected choices. Sparing Danbury could lead to new quests, encounters, or opportunities that you wouldn't have otherwise experienced.

My Personal Take

Personally, I usually lean towards sparing Danbury, at least on my first playthrough. I like to see how the story unfolds when I choose the more compassionate option. But hey, that's just me. The beauty of Red Dead Redemption 2 is that you can play it however you want. There's no right or wrong way to experience the game.

Final Thoughts

In the end, the decision of whether to kill Danbury is a personal one. Consider the consequences, weigh the pros and cons, and make a choice that feels right for your Arthur Morgan. And remember, in the Wild West, every action has a reaction. So choose wisely, partner!

Whether you decide to send Danbury to meet his maker or offer him a helping hand, remember that your choices shape your story in Red Dead Redemption 2. These random encounters are what make the game so immersive and engaging, and they force you to confront the moral ambiguities of the Wild West. So, next time you stumble upon a character like Danbury, take a moment to consider the implications of your actions. You never know what kind of adventure awaits you.

Happy trails, and may your bullets fly true!